11-19-2026
Summary: The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals held that an employer’s refusal to accommodate an employee’s request for leave beyond FMLA leave could be a violation of the ADA.
Facts: Karima Javanzad worked as a sales associate at the Appliance Factor in Colorado. In March 2020, Javanzad’s son contracted pneumonia, and she called in sick for a couple of days. Javanzad then became ill and let HR know that she could not return to work yet. Javanzad continued to communicate with HR, letting them know that she was feeling sick and identified her symptoms, including a cough and shortness of breath. Her doctor provided a note stating she likely had COVID-19 and advised her to stay home for at least the next ten days.
At HR’s request, Javanzad applied for FMLA medical leave and was granted 12 weeks of leave, ending on June 8. She continued to communicate, telling HR that she “got weak again” and was experiencing challenges with breathing, speaking, and eating. When June rolled around, Javanzad notified HR that she needed an endoscopy for gastric issues and provided a doctor’s note. She anticipated needing a couple more weeks and asked about potential options after her FMLA leave ended, including extra time off until the procedure was completed. After some back-and-forth, on June 8, HR told Javanzad that if she could not return to work, she would need to resign. When Javanzad did not respond, the company fired her. In the termination letter, the company noted her request for an FMLA extension due to a gastric disorder.
The EEOC and Javanzad sued, alleging that the Appliance Factory knew about her disability through conversations about her ongoing illness, and she had asked for a reasonable accommodation under the ADA by asking for a “few weeks” of additional leave.
Tenth Circuit Holding: The Court held that a reasonable jury could find Appliance Factory was on notice of Javanzad’s condition and that her request for additional leave was a “plausibly reasonable accommodation request” under the ADA.
The court conducted an in-depth, fact-specific analysis of the information shared by Javanzad and the company’s responses. These facts provided sufficient detail for a jury to find that the employer had adequate notice of her possible disability and need for accommodation. The Tenth Circuit highlighted that her request for a few additional weeks could allow a jury to find that the accommodation request was reasonable.
